Parenting Each Child Differently: What 8 Kids Taught Us
Eight kids taught us one thing above all: the parenting playbook gets rewritten for every child. Here’s why fair doesn’t always mean identical — and what the one constant always is.
If you came into parenting thinking you would figure out your first child, write down what worked, and then just repeat it — welcome to the club. We thought that too.
Then child number two arrived. And three. And, well, eight.
Eight kids. Eight completely different people.
Same house. Same parents. Same rules on the wall. And somehow, what worked beautifully for one child did absolutely nothing for the next one. One of ours needed to talk a hard day all the way out, right then, before bed. Another needed quiet first — a little space — and only then could the words come. Swap those two approaches and you got tears from both, and a long night for everybody.
That is not failure. That is parenting real people instead of a formula.
The playbook gets rewritten every time
Here is what 8 kids taught us: the parenting playbook you wrote for your first child gets rewritten for every child after.
What one child needs, another does not. One is motivated by a challenge. Another shuts down under pressure and blooms with encouragement. One needs a firm boundary stated once. Another needs the why behind it before it sticks — which is part of why How to Talk to Your Kids About Hard Things matters so much in a house full of different personalities.
That shows up in ordinary places, too. With money, one child saves every dollar without being told, while another needs a slower walk through spending and saving, the kind we laid out in How to Talk to Your Kids About Money. Same lesson. Different doorway in.
Fair, we learned, does not always mean identical. Fair means each child gets what they need to grow. Your kids do not need a copy of the same parenting. They need their parent, paying attention to who they actually are.
The one thing that never changes
If everything else gets adjusted — the approach, the timing, the tone, the explanation — is there anything that stays the same?
Yes. One thing.
Love. Consistent, unconditional, show-up-even-when-it-is-hard love.
That is the thing that never needs to be adjusted.
Your method may change. Some days, honestly, your confidence changes by lunchtime. But a child who knows, deep down, “My mom and dad love me, and that is not going anywhere” has a foundation nothing else can replace.
That is why connection sits underneath all of it. We said it in How to Stay Connected With Your Kids at Every Age: through the hard seasons and the easy ones, you stay. Different kids connect in different ways — a car ride, a shared laugh, a quiet check-in after a game — but the message is the same to every one of them: You are known, and you are loved.
You will get the “different” part wrong sometimes. We do. You will use the approach that worked on an older sibling, watch it flop, and have to apologize, adjust, and try again. That adjusting is not weakness. It is love learning a new child.
Try this today
Pick one child and ask yourself one simple question: What does this child actually need from me right now — not what worked on their brother or sister, but what works for them?
Then do one small thing based on your answer. Give the quiet one ten unhurried minutes instead of twenty questions. Give the talker your full attention for the story, all the way to the end. Encourage the sensitive one in private. Challenge the confident one directly, with trust in your voice.
One child. One adjustment. Today.
Let’s talk about it
Here is your conversation starter for tonight — ask your kids, one at a time if you can:
“How do you know we love you? What do we do that makes you feel it most?”
Do not correct the answers. Do not assume they will all say the same thing. They probably will not — and that is the whole point. Their answers are a map to parenting each of them a little more like themselves.
Eight kids taught us a lot of things, but this one sits near the top: every child is different. Love is the constant.
Want a short parenting insight like this in your inbox every morning? Get the Parenting Minute at fulllifecrew.com/parenting-minute — one tip, one activity, one conversation starter a day, free.
Explore Topics
Written by
Jareth & Deb
Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.